diff --git a/includes/logging/MoveLogFormatter.php b/includes/logging/MoveLogFormatter.php
index 39130163924..35da113ab58 100644
--- a/includes/logging/MoveLogFormatter.php
+++ b/includes/logging/MoveLogFormatter.php
@@ -37,8 +37,9 @@ class MoveLogFormatter extends LogFormatter {
 
 	protected function getMessageKey() {
 		$key = parent::getMessageKey();
-		$params = $this->getMessageParameters();
+		$params = $this->extractParameters();
 		if ( isset( $params[4] ) && $params[4] === '1' ) {
+			// Messages: logentry-move-move-noredirect, logentry-move-move_redir-noredirect
 			$key .= '-noredirect';
 		}
 
@@ -51,6 +52,7 @@ class MoveLogFormatter extends LogFormatter {
 		$newname = $this->makePageLink( Title::newFromText( $params[3] ) );
 		$params[2] = Message::rawParam( $oldname );
 		$params[3] = Message::rawParam( $newname );
+		unset( $params[4] ); // handled in getMessageKey
 
 		return $params;
 	}