wiki.techinc.nl/tests/phpunit/includes/user/PasswordResetTest.php
Thiemo Kreuz b95a07380a Remove meaningless ->expects( $this->any() ) from all tests
It is not entirely meaningless. It might be an indicator that
the number of calls to a method is intentionally unlimited.
This is similar to e.g. an @inheritDoc PHPDoc comment that
marks a method as being "intentionally undocumented".

However, what's the meaning of being "intentionally
unconstrained"? Let's just not have any constraint then.

I feel all these ->expects( $this->any() ) bloat the test
code so much that it's never worth it.

Change-Id: I9925e7706bd03e1666f6eb0b284cb42b0dd3be23
2021-04-23 11:58:58 +02:00

715 lines
24 KiB
PHP

<?php
use MediaWiki\Auth\AuthManager;
use MediaWiki\Auth\TemporaryPasswordAuthenticationRequest;
use MediaWiki\Block\CompositeBlock;
use MediaWiki\Block\DatabaseBlock;
use MediaWiki\Block\SystemBlock;
use MediaWiki\Config\ServiceOptions;
use MediaWiki\MediaWikiServices;
use MediaWiki\Permissions\PermissionManager;
use MediaWiki\User\UserFactory;
use MediaWiki\User\UserOptionsLookup;
use Psr\Log\NullLogger;
use Wikimedia\Rdbms\ILoadBalancer;
/**
* @covers PasswordReset
* @group Database
*/
class PasswordResetTest extends MediaWikiIntegrationTestCase {
private const VALID_IP = '1.2.3.4';
private const VALID_EMAIL = 'foo@bar.baz';
/**
* @dataProvider provideIsAllowed
*/
public function testIsAllowed( $passwordResetRoutes, $enableEmail,
$allowsAuthenticationDataChange, $canEditPrivate, $block, $globalBlock, $isAllowed
) {
$config = $this->makeConfig( $enableEmail, $passwordResetRoutes, false );
$authManager = $this->getMockBuilder( AuthManager::class )->disableOriginalConstructor()
->getMock();
$authManager->method( 'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' )
->willReturn( $allowsAuthenticationDataChange ? Status::newGood() : Status::newFatal( 'foo' ) );
$user = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )->getMock();
$user->method( 'getName' )->willReturn( 'Foo' );
$user->method( 'getBlock' )->willReturn( $block );
$user->method( 'getGlobalBlock' )->willReturn( $globalBlock );
$permissionManager = $this->getMockBuilder( PermissionManager::class )
->disableOriginalConstructor()
->getMock();
$permissionManager->method( 'userHasRight' )
->with( $user, 'editmyprivateinfo' )
->willReturn( $canEditPrivate );
$loadBalancer = $this->createMock( ILoadBalancer::class );
$hookContainer = $this->createHookContainer();
$mwServices = MediaWikiServices::getInstance();
$passwordReset = new PasswordReset(
$config,
new NullLogger(),
$authManager,
$hookContainer,
$loadBalancer,
$permissionManager,
$mwServices->getUserFactory(),
$mwServices->getUserNameUtils(),
$mwServices->getUserOptionsLookup()
);
$this->assertSame( $isAllowed, $passwordReset->isAllowed( $user )->isGood() );
}
public function provideIsAllowed() {
return [
'no routes' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => null,
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'email disabled' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => false,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => null,
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'auth data change disabled' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => false,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => null,
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'cannot edit private data' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => false,
'block' => null,
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'blocked with account creation disabled' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new DatabaseBlock( [ 'createAccount' => true ] ),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'blocked w/o account creation disabled' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new DatabaseBlock( [] ),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => true,
],
'using blocked proxy' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new SystemBlock(
[ 'systemBlock' => 'proxy' ]
),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'globally blocked with account creation not disabled' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => null,
'globalBlock' => new SystemBlock(
[ 'systemBlock' => 'global-block' ]
),
'isAllowed' => true,
],
'blocked via wgSoftBlockRanges' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new SystemBlock(
[ 'systemBlock' => 'wgSoftBlockRanges', 'anonOnly' => true ]
),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => true,
],
'blocked with an unknown system block type' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new SystemBlock( [ 'systemBlock' => 'unknown' ] ),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'blocked with multiple blocks, all allowing password reset' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new CompositeBlock( [
'originalBlocks' => [
new SystemBlock( [ 'systemBlock' => 'wgSoftBlockRanges', 'anonOnly' => true ] ),
new Block( [] ),
]
] ),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => true,
],
'blocked with multiple blocks, not all allowing password reset' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => new CompositeBlock( [
'originalBlocks' => [
new SystemBlock( [ 'systemBlock' => 'wgSoftBlockRanges', 'anonOnly' => true ] ),
new SystemBlock( [ 'systemBlock' => 'proxy' ] ),
]
] ),
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => false,
],
'all OK' => [
'passwordResetRoutes' => [ 'username' => true ],
'enableEmail' => true,
'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' => true,
'canEditPrivate' => true,
'block' => null,
'globalBlock' => null,
'isAllowed' => true,
],
];
}
public function testExecute_notAllowed() {
$user = $this->createMock( User::class );
/** @var User $user */
$passwordReset = $this->getMockBuilder( PasswordReset::class )
->disableOriginalConstructor()
->onlyMethods( [ 'isAllowed' ] )
->getMock();
$passwordReset->method( 'isAllowed' )
->with( $user )
->willReturn( Status::newFatal( 'somestatuscode' ) );
/** @var PasswordReset $passwordReset */
$this->expectException( \LogicException::class );
$passwordReset->execute( $user );
}
/**
* @dataProvider provideExecute
* @param string|bool $expectedError
* @param ServiceOptions $config
* @param User $performingUser
* @param PermissionManager $permissionManager
* @param AuthManager $authManager
* @param string|null $username
* @param string|null $email
* @param User[] $usersWithEmail
* @covers SendPasswordResetEmailUpdate
*/
public function testExecute(
$expectedError,
ServiceOptions $config,
User $performingUser,
PermissionManager $permissionManager,
AuthManager $authManager,
$username = '',
$email = '',
array $usersWithEmail = []
) {
// Unregister the hooks for proper unit testing
$this->mergeMwGlobalArrayValue( 'wgHooks', [
'User::mailPasswordInternal' => [],
'SpecialPasswordResetOnSubmit' => [],
] );
$loadBalancer = $this->createMock( ILoadBalancer::class );
$users = $this->makeUsers();
// Only User1 has `requireemail` true, everything else false
$userRequiresEmail = function ( $user, $option ) {
$this->assertSame( 'requireemail', $option );
return ( $user->getName() === 'User1' );
};
$userOptionsLookup = $this->getMockBuilder( UserOptionsLookup::class )
->onlyMethods( [ 'getBoolOption' ] )
->getMockForAbstractClass();
$userOptionsLookup->method( 'getBoolOption' )
->willReturnCallback( $userRequiresEmail );
// Similar to $lookupUser callback, but with null instead of false
$userFactory = $this->createMock( UserFactory::class );
$userFactory->method( 'newFromName' )
->willReturnCallback(
static function ( $username ) use ( $users ) {
return $users[ $username ] ?? null;
}
);
$lookupUser = static function ( $username ) use ( $users ) {
return $users[ $username ] ?? false;
};
$mwServices = MediaWikiServices::getInstance();
$passwordReset = $this->getMockBuilder( PasswordReset::class )
->onlyMethods( [ 'getUsersByEmail', 'isAllowed' ] )
->setConstructorArgs( [
$config,
new NullLogger(),
$authManager,
$mwServices->getHookContainer(),
$loadBalancer,
$permissionManager,
$userFactory,
$mwServices->getUserNameUtils(),
$userOptionsLookup
] )
->getMock();
$passwordReset->method( 'getUsersByEmail' )->with( $email )
->willReturn( array_map( $lookupUser, $usersWithEmail ) );
$passwordReset->method( 'isAllowed' )
->willReturn( Status::newGood() );
/** @var PasswordReset $passwordReset */
$status = $passwordReset->execute( $performingUser, $username, $email );
$this->assertStatus( $status, $expectedError );
}
public function provideExecute() {
$defaultConfig = $this->makeConfig( true, [ 'username' => true, 'email' => true ], false );
$emailRequiredConfig = $this->makeConfig( true, [ 'username' => true, 'email' => true ], true );
$performingUser = $this->makePerformingUser( self::VALID_IP, false );
$throttledUser = $this->makePerformingUser( self::VALID_IP, true );
$permissionManager = $this->makePermissionManager( $performingUser, true );
return [
'Throttled, pretend everything is ok' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $throttledUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Throttled, email required for resets, is invalid, pretend everything is ok' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $emailRequiredConfig,
'performingUser' => $throttledUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '[invalid email]',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Invalid email, pretend everything is OK' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => '',
'email' => '[invalid email]',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'No username, no email' => [
'expectedError' => 'passwordreset-nodata',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => '',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Email route not enabled' => [
'expectedError' => 'passwordreset-nodata',
'config' => $this->makeConfig( true, [ 'username' => true ], false ),
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => '',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Username route not enabled' => [
'expectedError' => 'passwordreset-nodata',
'config' => $this->makeConfig( true, [ 'email' => true ], false ),
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'No routes enabled' => [
'expectedError' => 'passwordreset-nodata',
'config' => $this->makeConfig( true, [], false ),
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Email required for resets but is empty, pretend everything is OK' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $emailRequiredConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Email required for resets but is invalid, pretend everything is OK' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $emailRequiredConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '[invalid email]',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Password email already sent within 24 hours, pretend everything is ok' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1' ], 0, [], [ 'User1' ] ),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1' ],
],
'No user by this username, pretend everything is OK' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'Nonexistent user',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Username is not valid' => [
'expectedError' => 'noname',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'Invalid|username',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'If no users with this email found, pretend everything is OK' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => '',
'email' => 'some@not.found.email',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'No email for the user, pretend everything is OK' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'BadUser',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'Email required for resets, no match' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $emailRequiredConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => 'some@other.email',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
"Couldn't determine the performing user's IP" => [
'expectedError' => 'badipaddress',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $this->makePerformingUser( null, false ),
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'User is allowed, but ignored' => [
'expectedError' => 'passwordreset-ignored',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1' ], 0, [ 'User1' ] ),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'One of users is ignored' => [
'expectedError' => 'passwordreset-ignored',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1', 'User2' ], 0, [ 'User2' ] ),
'username' => '',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1', 'User2' ],
],
'User is rejected' => [
'expectedError' => 'rejected by test mock',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager(),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => '',
'usersWithEmail' => [],
],
'One of users is rejected' => [
'expectedError' => 'rejected by test mock',
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1' ] ),
'username' => '',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1', 'User2' ],
],
'Reset one user via password' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1' ], 1 ),
'username' => 'User1',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
// Make sure that only the user specified by username is reset
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1', 'User2' ],
],
'Reset one user via email' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1' ], 1 ),
'username' => '',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1' ],
],
'Reset multiple users via email' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $defaultConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User1', 'User2' ], 2 ),
'username' => '',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1', 'User2' ],
],
"Email is required for resets, user didn't opt in" => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $emailRequiredConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User2' ], 1 ),
'username' => 'User2',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User2' ],
],
'Reset three users via email that did not opt in, multiple users with same email' => [
'expectedError' => false,
'config' => $emailRequiredConfig,
'performingUser' => $performingUser,
'permissionManager' => $permissionManager,
'authManager' => $this->makeAuthManager( [ 'User2', 'User3', 'User4' ], 3, [ 'User1' ] ),
'username' => '',
'email' => self::VALID_EMAIL,
'usersWithEmail' => [ 'User1', 'User2', 'User3', 'User4' ],
],
];
}
private function assertStatus( StatusValue $status, $error = false ) {
if ( $error === false ) {
$this->assertTrue(
$status->isGood(),
'Expected status to be good, result was: ' . $status->__toString()
);
} else {
$this->assertFalse( $status->isGood(), 'Expected status to not be good' );
if ( is_string( $error ) ) {
$this->assertNotEmpty( $status->getErrors() );
$message = $status->getErrors()[0]['message'];
if ( $message instanceof MessageSpecifier ) {
$message = $message->getKey();
}
$this->assertSame( $error, $message );
}
}
}
private function makeConfig( $enableEmail, array $passwordResetRoutes, $emailForResets ) {
$hash = [
'AllowRequiringEmailForResets' => $emailForResets,
'EnableEmail' => $enableEmail,
'PasswordResetRoutes' => $passwordResetRoutes,
];
return new ServiceOptions( PasswordReset::CONSTRUCTOR_OPTIONS, $hash );
}
/**
* @param string|null $ip
* @param bool $pingLimited
* @return User
*/
private function makePerformingUser( $ip, $pingLimited ) : User {
$request = $this->getMockBuilder( WebRequest::class )
->getMock();
$request->method( 'getIP' )
->willReturn( $ip );
/** @var WebRequest $request */
$user = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )
->onlyMethods( [ 'getName', 'pingLimiter', 'getRequest' ] )
->getMock();
$user->method( 'getName' )
->willReturn( 'SomeUser' );
$user->method( 'pingLimiter' )
->with( 'mailpassword' )
->willReturn( $pingLimited );
$user->method( 'getRequest' )
->willReturn( $request );
/** @var User $user */
return $user;
}
private function makePermissionManager( User $performingUser, $isAllowed ) : PermissionManager {
$permissionManager = $this->getMockBuilder( PermissionManager::class )
->disableOriginalConstructor()
->getMock();
$permissionManager->method( 'userHasRight' )
->with( $performingUser, 'editmyprivateinfo' )
->willReturn( $isAllowed );
/** @var PermissionManager $permissionManager */
return $permissionManager;
}
/**
* @param string[] $allowed Usernames that are allowed to send password reset email
* by AuthManager's allowsAuthenticationDataChange method.
* @param int $numUsersToAuth Number of users that will receive email
* @param string[] $ignored Usernames that are allowed but ignored by AuthManager's
* allowsAuthenticationDataChange method and will not receive password reset email.
* @param string[] $mailThrottledLimited Usernames that have already
* received the password reset email within a given time, and AuthManager
* changeAuthenticationData method will mark them as 'throttled-mailpassword.'
* @return AuthManager
*/
private function makeAuthManager(
array $allowed = [],
$numUsersToAuth = 0,
array $ignored = [],
array $mailThrottledLimited = []
) : AuthManager {
$authManager = $this->getMockBuilder( AuthManager::class )
->disableOriginalConstructor()
->getMock();
$authManager->method( 'allowsAuthenticationDataChange' )
->willReturnCallback(
static function ( TemporaryPasswordAuthenticationRequest $req )
use ( $allowed, $ignored, $mailThrottledLimited ) {
if ( in_array( $req->username, $mailThrottledLimited, true ) ) {
return Status::newGood( 'throttled-mailpassword' );
}
$value = in_array( $req->username, $ignored, true )
? 'ignored'
: 'okie dokie';
return in_array( $req->username, $allowed, true )
? Status::newGood( $value )
: Status::newFatal( 'rejected by test mock' );
} );
// changeAuthenticationData is executed in the deferred update class
// SendPasswordResetEmailUpdate
$authManager->expects( $this->exactly( $numUsersToAuth ) )
->method( 'changeAuthenticationData' );
/** @var AuthManager $authManager */
return $authManager;
}
/**
* @return User[]
*/
private function makeUsers() {
$user1 = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )->getMock();
$user2 = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )->getMock();
$user3 = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )->getMock();
$user4 = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )->getMock();
$user1->method( 'getName' )->willReturn( 'User1' );
$user2->method( 'getName' )->willReturn( 'User2' );
$user3->method( 'getName' )->willReturn( 'User3' );
$user4->method( 'getName' )->willReturn( 'User4' );
$user1->method( 'getId' )->willReturn( 1 );
$user2->method( 'getId' )->willReturn( 2 );
$user3->method( 'getId' )->willReturn( 3 );
$user4->method( 'getId' )->willReturn( 4 );
$user1->method( 'getEmail' )->willReturn( self::VALID_EMAIL );
$user2->method( 'getEmail' )->willReturn( self::VALID_EMAIL );
$user3->method( 'getEmail' )->willReturn( self::VALID_EMAIL );
$user4->method( 'getEmail' )->willReturn( self::VALID_EMAIL );
$badUser = $this->getMockBuilder( User::class )->getMock();
$badUser->method( 'getName' )->willReturn( 'BadUser' );
$badUser->method( 'getId' )->willReturn( 5 );
$badUser->method( 'getEmail' )->willReturn( '' );
return [
'User1' => $user1,
'User2' => $user2,
'User3' => $user3,
'User4' => $user4,
'BadUser' => $badUser,
];
}
}